Not entirely sure why this was happening, but I was seeing the incorrect number of Unconscious Dudes indicated on the Dude Juices. For example, I'd have say 3 to 4 Bards become unconscious, nobody is knocked out from a previous round, and yet the Dude Juices would say 5. I thought it was just a weird glitch and it'd work itself out, but it was an issue through the remainder of my run, and I ended up having to hover over Dude Juices while keeping an eye on my roster to determine when 5+ Dudes had actually dropped.